CHINA’S LEADERS haven’t any qualms about utilizing intimidation and pressure to stay in power. But the Communist Party additionally claims that it deserves to rule as a result of it governs properly and has the help of the general public. Officials level to many years of spectacular financial progress—and to opinion surveys that researchers at Harvard University carried out between 2003 and 2016. In the final such survey, over 90% of Chinese folks expressed satisfaction with the get together. “Such high approval ratings are beyond the wildest dreams of American politicians,” boasted Hua Chunying, a foreign-ministry spokeswoman, in 2020.

Gauging public opinion in China is tough. Foreign companies are usually banned from finishing up surveys. Chinese pollsters are inclined to keep away from sticky topics, although some work with Western researchers (this was how Harvard carried out its research). No matter who’s asking the questions, respondents might not share their precise views for worry of reprisal. So researchers on the University of Southern California tried to get round this drawback through the use of a survey methodology referred to as a “list experiment”. Their findings, printed this month, recommend that the Communist Party has fewer followers than beforehand thought.

The researchers divided individuals of their survey (carried out on-line) into two teams. Those within the first have been proven three anodyne statements, reminiscent of “I consider myself a sports fan”. Those within the second have been proven the identical three objects plus one delicate assertion, reminiscent of “I support Comrade Xi Jinping’s leadership”, or “China’s system of government is better than any other I can think of”.

Respondents in each teams have been then requested what number of statements they agreed with, with out having to establish them. This allowed them to specific their political beliefs not directly. By subtracting the typical of the primary group from that of the second group, the researchers have been capable of estimate the share of respondents who agreed with the delicate assertion.

The outcomes recommend that when the survey was carried out in June and November 2020 between 50% and 70% of Chinese folks supported the get together. (This is an higher certain, say the researchers, as a result of considerations about on-line surveillance should have spooked some respondents into giving constructive responses.) Around half of respondents didn’t agree that China’s system of presidency is greatest. Nearly 40% mentioned they have been “afraid of the consequences” of protesting in opposition to the state. Support for Mr Xi was between 65% and 70%.

His approval ranking has most likely fallen since then. Mr Xi’s “zero-covid” coverage angered many Chinese, who grew uninterested in the fixed testing and lockdowns. When the federal government finally dropped its pandemic controls on the finish of 2022, analysts predicted a giant rebound in financial exercise. But customers stay gloomy and plenty of younger Chinese are struggling to seek out jobs.

Even if it has fallen, Mr Xi’s ranking might nonetheless be the envy of Western politicians. A paltry 33% of Americans approve of the job President Joe Biden is doing, in response to a current ballot. Still, the outcomes of the research would possibly concern China’s leaders. The Communist Party depends on the (round) presumption that the general public thinks that it’s overwhelmingly common. If disgruntled residents consider they’re in a small minority they’re much less prone to talk about political points, not to mention resist the get together. But in the event that they consider there are a lot of others like them, dissent might snowball, says Erin Baggott Carter, an writer of the research.

There is not any signal that China’s Communist Party is about to face a revolution. But get together officers are eager college students of historical past. They are haunted by the collapse of communist regimes in japanese Europe, the place opposition actions grew shortly as soon as folks realised their anger was widespread. Mr Xi has ordered his propagandists to “adhere to the correct guidance of public opinion”. They would possibly level to a special survey, carried out in November by Edelman, an American consultancy. In that one 85% of Chinese expressed belief of their authorities. That was second greatest among the many 28 international locations surveyed. The agency didn’t use an inventory experiment.

Subscribers can signal as much as Drum Tower, our new weekly e-newsletter, to know what the world makes of China—and what China makes of the world.

© 2023, The Economist Newspaper Limited. All rights reserved. From The Economist, printed underneath licence. The unique content material may be discovered on www.economist.com