“NIhao, china” is the title of the nation’s newest effort to draw international guests. The brand accompanying the phrase (which suggests “hello, China”) contains a panda—a picture all the time useful when China desires to look cuddly. Chinese officers have been touring the West to advertise the marketing campaign, helped by a video wherein happy-looking foreigners intone the Chinese greeting. Those with a deeper grasp of the language would possibly sense a special temper, together with billboards on metropolis streets warning folks to look out for international spies, and authorities propaganda on social media urging vigilance towards threats to nationwide safety. The Communist Party typically tells Chinese those who vacationers, journalists and businesspeople might all be after the nation’s secrets and techniques.

More than a yr after China scrapped its “zero-covid” coverage, which had saved it sealed off from most international guests from early 2020 to the top of 2022, the nation is now pushing in two contradictory instructions. Parts of the federal government seem wanting to courtroom foreigners. Last month China despatched a big delegation to the World Economic Forum in Davos, Switzerland. Li Qiang, the prime minister, informed the gathering that “no matter how the world changes, China will…open its door still wider to the world.”

In a minimum of one key respect that is true: China’s commerce in greenback phrases is 31% increased than in 2019. But The Economist has checked out a spread of different measures, from visits to China by international vacationers and flight numbers to ranges of educational alternate, funding flows and even the non-public journey schedule of China’s chief, Xi Jinping. They counsel a rustic overshadowed by a profoundly altering relationship with the West, a extra security-driven fashion of policymaking at residence and by the parlous state of its economic system. China has develop into extra inward-looking; the West extra cautious.

China disaster

At essentially the most primary degree, far fewer outsiders are crossing borders into China. Last yr the nation recorded about 62m fewer entries and exits by foreigners than in 2019, earlier than the pandemic started: a drop of greater than 63%. Behind these figures lie deeper traits. Take the geopolitical setting. In the three years throughout which China shut its borders to stop the unfold of COVID-19, and its leaders hunkered at residence, the West—led by America—was engaged in a wide-ranging re-think of how to deal with China’s rise as a world energy.

President Donald Trump centered on attempting to chop America’s commerce deficit with China, however his administration sought to push again on different fronts, together with efforts to include China’s army exercise. There was no let-up after Joe Biden took over in 2021. In the next yr, Russia’s invasion of Ukraine drove the wedge between the West and China even deeper. China referred to as itself a “no-limits” companion of Russia. Mr Biden ramped up controls on the export to China of superior semiconductors.

The invasion threw up an sudden impediment to the restoration of regular flows of individuals between China and America. In response to Russia’s aggression, America and its allies barred Russian airways from utilizing their airspace. Russia imposed a tit-for-tat ban. This has impeded the re-opening of aviation routes between America and China that have been severed throughout the pandemic: America doesn’t wish to give a bonus to Chinese airways by permitting routes to re-open, when these airways might save time and gasoline, and due to this fact achieve passengers, by flying over Russia.

At a gathering in November, Mr Biden and Mr Xi agreed to “work towards a significant further increase in scheduled passenger flights”. But by the top of 2023, there are nonetheless solely 63 direct ones between the 2 nations per week, far fewer than the roughly 300 flights that have been in operation earlier than the pandemic (see map). According to FlightAware, an American flight-tracking web site, Chinese airways are avoiding Russia on newly accredited routes.

In half, America is guilty for a discount in contacts between the 2 nations that have been as soon as thought-about routine. In 2022 it ended a Trump-era marketing campaign by the Department of Justice, referred to as the China Initiative, whose purpose was ferreting out Chinese spies in American academia and enterprise. It had develop into mired in accusations of racial profiling. But ditching this has not put scientists comfy.

Worried about being accused of serving to China by sharing superior know-how, American researchers have develop into more and more cautious of collaborating with their Chinese counterparts. In 2020 the variety of science papers collectively produced by Chinese and American researchers started to fall. “That is certainly a consequence of the political environment” in America, says Jonathan Adams of Clarivate, an analytics agency. Of China’s internationally collaborative analysis papers, the share involving American co-authors has fallen from a peak of 47% in 2013 to 32% in 2022, the corporate’s information present.

At America’s borders, officers have develop into twitchier about Chinese getting into for research. Chinese diplomats complain that some college students with legitimate visas are being subjected to prolonged interrogations, typically about Chinese authorities backing for his or her initiatives. They say a number of of them have been despatched again. Deborah Seligsohn of Villanova University in Pennsylvania, who has been learning Sino-American exchanges in science, says she is aware of Chinese lecturers whose analysis is “completely uncontroversial” and who’ve been subjected to such questioning.

Among foreigners mulling journeys to China, recollections have been gradual to fade of China’s generally brutal enforcement of its zero-covid measures. China now all however ignores COVID-19 (it abolished the final vestige of pandemic management in November, by ending the necessity to fill out a health-declaration kind on arrival). But potential guests are “still fearful at the back of their minds about potential lockdowns,” says John Grant of Oag, a travel-data agency. “You know, the horror stories that we’ve all heard about…all of that impacts consumers’ perceptions of the market.”

Journey to the West

China’s state-controlled media likes to focus on examples of American mistreatment of Chinese folks. Such circumstances function a propaganda marketing campaign that portrays the West as racist and a builder of obstacles and of menacing safety networks which might be geared toward preserving an harmless China as an alternative. Perhaps deliberately, this depiction of the West could also be deterring some Chinese college students from going to America: within the tutorial yr of 2022-23 they numbered about 290,000, down from a peak of greater than 370,000 in 2019-20.

Mr Xi likes to current his personal nation as a champion of world engagement (in a world laden with doubt about globalisation, he describes it with putting confidence as an “irreversible trend of the times”). In actuality, he appears much less inclined to journey overseas. In 2023, after the higher a part of three years with out venturing abroad, he spent solely 13 days exterior the nation in contrast with a extra typical 28 days in 2019. In September final yr, he shunned an annual gathering of g20 leaders in India, regardless of having attended earlier such occasions in particular person or on-line. He did, nevertheless, journey to San Francisco in November for a summit of the Asia-Pacific Economic Co-operation discussion board. There, at his first face-to-face assembly with Mr Biden for a yr, he insisted that for America and China, “turning their back on each other is not an option”.

Many Chinese officers survey their struggling economic system, with its collapsing property companies and mountains of debt, and nonetheless see advantages to be gained from the West’s markets, capital and know-how. Mr Xi is sustaining army stress on Taiwan however doesn’t seem prepared for an all-out conflict with the West that an assault could entail. In December China resumed military-to-military communications with America, having suspended them for greater than a yr in protest towards high-level contact between America and Taiwan. The door is barely ajar: China’s armed forces share little in such dialogue. But the message is that Mr Xi desires a steady relationship with the West. He seems to not need Westerners to hurry for the exits.

That is obvious within the “Nihao, China” marketing campaign. Since December vacationers from France, Germany, Italy, the Netherlands, Spain and Switzerland, in addition to Malaysia, have been allowed to go to China visa-free for 15 days. Russians could also be shut associates, however they don’t take pleasure in such a concession.

Many Western businesspeople, nevertheless, take a look at China’s shaky economic system and the federal government’s heavy hand over it, and fear. Foreign direct funding in greenfield initiatives in China has declined from greater than $87bn in 2013 to lower than $18bn in 2022. Flows of portfolio funding into China have been adverse for the previous 4 quarters as world funds dump Chinese equities. Foreign businesspeople are anxious in regards to the rising assertiveness of China’s secret police: raids final yr on international consulting companies in China rang alarm bells. On February 1st the American Chamber of Commerce in China launched its annual survey of member firms’ temper. Nearly 40% mentioned they believed international companies have been much less welcome in China than they have been in 2022, a yr when many companies have been battered by covid-related lockdowns. Mr Xi is “living in his own world, surrounded by the security people”, says a outstanding Western businessman in Beijing. “And then you have these economic decision-makers around him who find it very difficult to find time with him, to alert him and to stop this erosion in sentiment.”

Mr Xi retains railing towards what he sees as “ideological infiltration” by the West, and speaking up the necessity to make China’s economic system “self-reliant”. The West’s heightened resolve to counteract dangerous behaviour by China overseas has stiffened its sinews. In response to America’s chip struggle, his authorities is pumping cash into Chinese firms to assist them produce cutting-edge know-how by themselves.

The east is bread

What in regards to the huge exception to the pattern of isolation, China’s hovering commerce flows, which replicate its persevering with position as an industrial powerhouse? Even they inform a narrative. During Mr Xi’s rule, the share of China’s international commerce with main rich-world economies has been falling. In current years, commerce with the ten-member Association of South-East Asian Nations and the opposite nations of brics—specifically Brazil, Russia, India and South Africa—has grown extra quickly than its commerce with Europe and America.

For Mr Xi, though America stays essential, “South-South cooperation” is rising quick as a strategic and financial precedence. What he means by that is the creation of an alternate centre of world energy—one which pivots round China, with the West at a protected distance. China is stepping up efforts to woo nations of the “Global South”, as Mr Xi calls it, attempting to safe them to China’s orbit with implicit guarantees of financial achieve in return for his or her acquiescence to China’s worldview. China is opening a brand new door. This time it’s setting the phrases for these allowed to enter.

© 2023, The Economist Newspaper Limited. All rights reserved. From The Economist, printed underneath licence. The unique content material will be discovered on www.economist.com