“She was criticized for her look; she was criticized for not being ladylike enough. There were comments made in the press, that she should be home sitting by the phone, waiting for a suitor to call her as opposed to being out competing. It was very harsh, negative, critical things. And they hurt her deeply.”

‘American sports heroine’

The daughter of immigrants from Norway, sport always played a big part in Zaharias’ life.

From baseball and basketball to track and field and tennis, Zaharias seemingly excelled at whichever sport she turned her hand to. She earned her nickname “Babe” as a result of her baseball ability and comparisons between her and Babe Ruth.

The pinnacle of her athletic career coincided with the 1932 Olympic Games in Los Angeles, a time when athletes, unlike today, didn’t always specialize in one sport, but often entered multiple disciplines in the hopes of achieving success.

Women, however, were unable to enter more than three events, so Zaharias participated in the javelin, high jump and 80m hurdles.

Van Natta Jr. believes that Zaharias could have won more medals had she been allowed to compete in a greater number of events.

“I don’t know about gold medals, but I think she could have medaled in probably at least five [sports],” he said.

“She came in first place, just among obviously her American counterparts, at the event at Northwestern [University] that was the qualifying event for the Olympics, and she won five of those events. So I believe she could have been medaled in five (javelin, hurdles, high jump, 100m sprint and discus) easily if she had been allowed to.”

Beginnings

In the 1930s, it was difficult for women to earn any sort of living in athletics due to an almost total lack of prize money and sponsorship opportunities.

“Babe was very much thinking about a way to make a living as a sports woman,” Van Natta Jr. said. “And so she figured out that golf was one of the places that you could actually do it, even though a lot of the events were amateur events. But if you succeeded at them, she figured she could market herself and find some income that way.”

Zaharias took up golf with a “competitiveness that was beyond fierce,” Susan Cayleff — who authored two books about Zaharias’ life — explained.

“She would drive golf balls until her palms bled and didn’t set any kind of realistic limit on herself in terms of physical expectations,” she said.

“They barred her in part because of a snob aspect,” said Van Natta Jr. “She was seen from the wrong side of the tracks, she was seen as a poor woman, she was coarse in the way she carried herself. She started defeating these wealthier women, well connected women to the USGA, so they knocked her out for a while.”

Standing out

With her husband’s help, she became a “huge draw for the crowds,” Van Natta Jr. notes, with her “chattering” nature making her one of the sport’s biggest draws.

However, her lack of femininity — “telling bawdy jokes and swearing, sometimes spitting, drinking,” according to Cayleff — and the perceived “working class, gritty, sweaty” nature of track and field competition put Zaharias at odds with her more traditional female competitors.

Cayleff describes Zaharias as being a “gender trickster” as she behaved “in ways that were absolutely contradictory to ideal femininity.”

“They took her uniqueness and what I refer to as her gender outlaw status,” Cayleff said. “They take her behaviors and, particularly before she’s married, absolutely craft her as a freak with newspaper headlines like: ‘Mr., Miss or It?’ or ‘Which bathroom should Babe Didrikson use?’

“They feared or presumed she was lesbian and then a particular term was coined in reference to her. She was called a ‘muscle moll’ or a member of a third sex. People were baffled and troubled by her gender presentation and particularly women golfers who tended to be of a more upper-class background and fancied themselves refined; they demonized her.”

Conforming

To counter the negative coverage, Zaharias recruited the help of Bertha Bowen, a Dallas socialite, who taught her how to “apply makeup, how to wear a girdle and get her hair styled,” Cayleff explains.

“She was the subject of absolutely vicious press after the 1932 Olympics where people were openly speculating and disparaging her sexuality and the like. And she understood, with the guidance of Bertha, that if she wanted to earn a living and keep her name in the public that she needed to seriously craft an image because who she legitimately was, was not someone that the American public was easy to embrace.”

Although she did a lot for the sport for women, Cayleff contends that Zaharias was not a “self-conscious role model or promoter of opportunity for women in sports.”

Cayleff recalls an incident she found while doing research for her book when Zaharias threatened to withdraw from a tournament going into the final round, despite leading by several shots, because, in her eyes, the prize money was not enough.

“Babe was out for Babe. In an instance like that, she was an absolute impact on increasing the purse in women’s golf, but it was not for the betterment of the sport or the betterment of the female athletes in general. It was for Babe.

“It’s a sort of mixed legacy. Yes, she absolutely impacted opportunities for athletes that came after her and athletes during her own lifetime, but she was in no way what we would call a feminist or gender conscious or concerned about equity in general,” Cayleff said. “She was concerned about a good payday for her and let the chips fall where they may be on that.”

Legacy

Zaharias chose to go public with her fight against cancer. This decision — plus her remarkable comeback and her extensive work with the American Cancer Society — helped change her perception in the eyes of both the public and the media, with Cayleff saying that it “heroized her in some ways to a new generation.”

“She was honored by President Eisenhower for her work with the American Cancer Society and did considerable fundraising for cancer research,” Cayleff said. “The cancer work and the ability to come back and compete successfully was pretty much unheard of at that point. She was told she would never be able to compete again. And like she had done so many times in her life, she just tripled her efforts and determined she would prove them wrong.”