In June, Tamil Nadu performed Haryana on the finals of the 2023 Senior Women’s National Football Championship in Amritsar. By the fifty-sixth minute, Haryana led 0-1. Soon after, Tamil Nadu participant Priyadarshini S rose over her friends within the opponents’ penalty field and guided a strong header into the underside nook of the aim. Her teammates rushed to her and swallowed the participant right into a joyful embrace.

Almost 3,000 km away within the city of Mannargudi in Tamil Nadu’s Thiruvarur district, a gaggle of younger youngsters huddled round a tiny mobile phone additionally erupted in celebrations. These have been 20-year-old Priyadarshini’s juniors and former classmates, who watched the match on-line between their soccer apply periods. Tamil Nadu went on to win the championship that day, beating Haryana with a second aim.

After the match, Priyadarshini’s first name was to not her dad and mom, however to the bodily schooling instructor on the Adi Dravidar (Scheduled Caste) Welfare High School, within the village of Savalakaran, by which she had studied. “I told him excitedly that we had won the final and that I had scored a goal,” Priyadarshini recalled, as we sat at a roadside tender coconut water stall in Savalakaran, on a vivid and sultry day in September. “He told me that he had just watched it all happen and that everyone was very proud of me.”

Overhearing our dialog, the curious stall proprietor requested us what we have been speaking about. “About Muthu Kumar sir,” Priyadarshini mentioned. Immediately, the girl mentioned that Muthu Kumar had introduced nice pleasure to their little village of Savalakaran. “It is only because of him, that people know about our village,” she mentioned. “They recognise it as the village where all the children play football.”

This story is a part of Common Ground, our in-depth and investigative reporting venture. Sign up here to get a recent story in your inbox each Wednesday.

The pleasure that Kumar’s work brings to Savalakaran belies the struggles that academics like him endure to impart bodily schooling to their college students.

For one, they’re usually unable to seek out safe jobs, regardless of a big scarcity of such academics in authorities colleges within the state.

The highest posts for academics within the discipline are of bodily administrators, who can solely be appointed to larger secondary colleges, which have grades as much as the twelfth. Of 3,877 authorities and government-aided larger secondary colleges within the state, solely 749 have a publish for a bodily director, in response to the Physical Education Teachers and Physical Education Directors Association of Tamil Nadu. Teachers will also be appointed in posts one rank under, as bodily schooling academics, in each larger secondary and excessive colleges, which have lessons as much as the tenth. Of the overall of seven,577 such colleges within the state, there are 6,500 posts for bodily schooling academics – that’s, greater than 1,000 do not need a instructor.

The scenario is worse at decrease ranges. The state has round 9,000 authorities and government-aided center colleges, which enrol college students as much as Class 8 – there are solely 40 posts for bodily schooling academics in these colleges. Of the state’s 29,459 authorities and government-aided major colleges, by which college students as much as Class 5 examine, there may be not even a single publish for a bodily schooling instructor.

In administrative phrases, bodily administrators maintain “grade one” posts, for which candidates will need to have a grasp’s diploma, whereas bodily schooling academics maintain “grade two” posts, for which they want a bachelor’s diploma. Below these are “secondary grade” posts, for which candidates solely must have a instructor’s coaching diploma.

“Those hired in this category make over 10,000 rupees less than their counterparts,” Suresh mentioned. He added that lots of them have bachelor’s levels, and a few even have grasp’s levels, however they’re unable to use for a place with larger pay just because there are not any posts obtainable.

Suresh famous that this third class of posts had been distributed with for different topic academics, however remained in place for bodily schooling academics. “Some tried for 30 years to get a better-paying position and eventually retired as second-grade category teachers,” he mentioned.

Some academics are solely given part-time appointments. In 2011, academics like Kumar have been recruited as a part of a mixed initiative of the Centre and state governments to rent extra particular topic academics, to supply college students with the chance to accumulate totally different expertise. These academics, of topics akin to music, sports activities, and humanities and crafts, have been employed on a part-time foundation for a wage of Rs 5,000.

For over a decade now, these part-time academics have been demanding that their positions be made everlasting. “They have been persistent in their demands,” Suresh mentioned. “But nobody is lending them an ear.”

News reviews counsel that the low precedence assigned to bodily schooling is just not an issue distinctive to Tamil Nadu. In Karnataka, in response to one report, in 2015, solely 11,447 of the 26,953 authorities larger major and excessive colleges had bodily schooling academics. In 2016, bodily schooling academics in Uttarakhand went on strike to demand the creation of seven,000 posts in authorities colleges. In Delhi in 2017, one report famous that fifty% of the posts in authorities colleges lay vacant.

The vacancies maybe replicate the dearth of social recognition for bodily schooling academics. “In most cases, a physical education teacher is often the first to notice talent in a potential sportsperson and provide the support that they need in order to get to a stage where they can get more professional training,” mentioned Suresh. “Yet, if an individual succeeds nationally or internationally, the credit always only goes to their coach. Everyone forgets the teacher.”

On a sunny September morning, I took the lengthy and winding Thiruvarur-Muthupet street and lower by means of kilometres of lush paddy fields, to seek out sudden splashes of color amidst the inexperienced – youngsters in brightly colored jerseys and tee-shirts. Two white goalposts stood at both finish of a small clearing between the paddy farms. Boys and women aged between 9 and 20 had cut up up into teams and kicked footballs round. Forty-six-year-old Kumar, who had been on the floor since 8 am, was standing close to one of many aim posts, giving college students instructions.

As the gamers wound up at round 10 am, after 4 hours in blistering warmth, they ran as much as Kumar to ask him when they need to be again for his or her second spherical of apply. He directed them to collect at 2 pm on the village bus cease. They deliberate to set off to the district’s principal sports activities floor in the midst of Thiruvarur metropolis, an hour away. This was a typical ritual on weekends, the one time the youngsters had some respite from their lessons.

The quantity of labor that Kumar, who has a diploma in bodily schooling, places in is much better than what he’s paid for. Under his part-time contract, he’s anticipated to go to the varsity three days every week, for 3 hours every day. But he teaches on the faculty day by day, usually arriving earlier than class hours and staying on for a lot of hours after.

When he joined, he was paid Rs 5,000 for this work – now, greater than ten years later, his pay has risen to simply Rs 10,000. The college students wanted all of the apply they might get, he mentioned, including that coaching them for 3 hours on simply three days wouldn’t suffice. Even although he was solely employed to show Class 6 and upwards, Kumar took it upon himself to coach youthful college students additionally.

When Kumar first arrived on the faculty, he was dismayed to seek out that it had no correct playground or sports activities gear. The space of the bottom was too small for any sport to be correctly performed – so he began off small, with video games of kho kho and a few working. But it proved tough to make sure that all the scholars acquired coaching.

Kumar mentioned he learnt round 5 years in the past that the panchayat had a small piece of land between paddy fields that was mendacity unused. Kumar secured permission from the panchayat to make use of the land – the scholars took it on themselves to work on the land and easy out the floor in order that they might use it as a soccer discipline. But Kumar famous that it was nonetheless removed from sufficient for severe apply, which was why he usually escorted them to the district’s principal discipline.

To fund these actions, and pay for gear and uniforms, Kumar mentioned he’s closely reliant on the prize cash that pupil groups win at matches. A workforce’s winnings are pooled in to pay for its gear, footwear and different bills. But this cash doesn’t all the time suffice, so usually Kumar dips into his personal wage. “Even a football costs Rs 1,000,” he mentioned. “Shoes also cost about the same amount, and nobody takes into account the transport costs when students have to travel outside for matches.”

David Rajan, one other part-time instructor, in Thiruvarur city, additionally spoke of dealing with grave monetary difficulties. After 12 years as a instructor, he now earns Rs 10,000. He mentioned that lots of his college students had competed on the state and nationwide ranges – of those, many had gone on to safe authorities jobs by means of quotas put aside for sportspersons, and risen within the ranks. “All of them are in better positions and earn much more than I do,” he mentioned. While he mentioned he was happy with them, he additionally felt appreciable disappointment for his family.

A couple of years in the past, when Rajan was given a switch, he determined to take it. But phrase in regards to the switch shortly unfold within the faculty. Students and their dad and mom turned up on the faculty, crying and begging him to remain. The faculty’s affiliation of oldsters and academics approached the District Education Officer, demanding that the switch be revoked. “The officers told me that I could turn down the transfer if I wanted, and remain in the same school,” Rajan mentioned. “So I stayed.”

Rajan mentioned he was moved by the gestures from his college students and others.

But his monetary struggles haven’t been alleviated – he mentioned he has by no means been in a position to purchase toys for his younger son, or a present for his spouse, and that he can barely help his ageing mom, significantly now that he has simply had one other little one. “My rent alone is Rs 5,500,” he mentioned. “How am I supposed to manage?”

Rajan has attended a number of protests in Chennai together with different bodily schooling academics, demanding full-time positions and will increase in salaries. Among the affiliation’s calls for are that the federal government sanction no less than one bodily director publish in all excessive colleges and better secondary colleges, and no less than one bodily schooling instructor publish in all major and center colleges. They are additionally demanding that the 6,500 academics who at present work at excessive colleges and better secondary colleges be promoted to bodily administrators.

D Rajadevakanth, the state secretary of the part-time academics affiliation mentioned that academics had protested 13 occasions in Chennai within the final 11 years, and about 20 occasions in several districts in the identical time. Over 1,000 part-time academics held a ten-day protest late final month.

Among their complaints is that not like common academics, part-time academics will not be paid their salaries for the month of May as a result of colleges don’t perform that month. “We somehow manage the month of May with April’s salary but we start the new academic year completely broke,” Rajadevakanth mentioned. “Even to travel we have to borrow money from others. Most part-time teachers are severely depressed because of financial challenges.”

The authorities responded by climbing part-time academics’ salaries by Rs 2,000 and providing them medical health insurance. “But there is no word on whether they will make our jobs permanent,” Rajadevakanth mentioned.

Rajan mentioned that he generally considers leaving his job and discovering one with higher pay. “But what if they end up increasing the salary after I leave?” he mentioned. “I don’t want to take that risk, so I’m just waiting.”

The academics additionally wrestle for funds for upkeep – Rajan’s faculty floor, as an example, is overgrown with weeds. Money for this work ought to come from the Samagra Shiksha programme, funded by each the Centre and states. The programme budgets as much as Rs 5,000 per 12 months for major colleges, as much as Rs 10,000 for higher major colleges, and as much as Rs 25,000 for prime colleges. It additionally assures an extra Rs 25,000 for any faculty the place no less than two college students win medals at Khelo India, an annual national-level athletics and sports activities competitions for varsity and faculty college students.

However, Kumar and lots of different academics mentioned that in lots of situations, below the programme the federal government offers colleges with supplies as an alternative of cash. They famous that the merchandise have been usually of poor high quality or didn’t go well with the wants of the scholars. “If they just gave us the money, we would know exactly what to buy, because each school has different needs,” Rajan mentioned.

In Rajan’s cobwebbed workplace, previous and dusty gear lay round. From one of many packing containers, he pulled out a number of footballs, basketballs and tennikoit rings, and confirmed tears on them. “They barely last a month,” he mentioned. “Just pump air into them and they burst.” He additionally picked up a bamboo pole and mentioned that college students used it to practise their pole-vaulting expertise, since they weren’t given an expert pole of fiberglass or carbon fibre. Rajan mentioned that in his 12 years on the faculty, these sporting supplies had been supplied solely twice.

T Deviselvam is the president of the Physical Education Teachers and Physical Education Directors Welfare Association, and has been a instructor for nearly 30 years at a authorities faculty. On the wall of his workplace are hockey competitors shields the varsity had received, courting again to the Fifties.

“As a school, we have always been known for our hockey team,” Deviselvam mentioned. “So logically, it would help us if we got hockey equipment because that is our main sport, but that does not happen.” He added, “Authorities don’t take our needs into consideration.”

He famous that they have been usually supplied substandard gear, like cricket bats made from plastic. “That shows how much importance sports is given,” he mentioned.

In some instances, academics are denied funds as a result of authorities argue that colleges lack amenities the place they can be utilized.

D Raju, a 50-year-old instructor in a authorities faculty in Thiruvarur, who, like Kumar, has skilled many athletes in his 18 years as a instructor, recounted that he had confronted his downside. Raju started his profession at a non-public faculty however shifted to a authorities faculty inside a number of years. “I was passionate about helping children from poorer and rural communities,” he mentioned. “So getting a government job felt like the one way to do it.” But the varsity he joined lacked a playground, so the scholars skilled on the district’s principal playground.

Many of the scholars that he skilled competed on the state and nationwide ranges, Raju mentioned. “Since I was seeing so much success, I felt I could demand that the authorities provide more funds for better equipment,” he mentioned. So he approached the Sports Development Authority with such requests. But his efforts have been unsuccessful. “They said even if we give you funds, where are you going to play? You have no playground. Where will you even store the equipment,” he recounted.

Disappointed, Raju switched to a different faculty, which had a playground. “They gave me some special funding and I used it to improve the school grounds and buy equipment,” he mentioned.

The determination to resign was not simple. “The students were upset,” he mentioned. “But I wanted to be able to fully use my skills and produce more athletes.” He added, “There were several schools close to my house, but none had a playground. So I chose to join a school 15 km away, just because they had a playground.”

A few kilometres away from Rajan’s faculty is a authorities faculty that has not had a bodily schooling instructor for the final ten years. “For about three years, we had a part-time teacher coming in, but he left,” mentioned the principal of the varsity, who requested to stay nameless. So, through the bodily schooling interval, youngsters simply run round and play, he defined.

That bodily schooling is commonly relegated to a secondary standing was obvious from a subsequent comment by the principal. “It helps to have a physical education teacher because they are the ones that usually help maintain discipline on campus,” he mentioned.

Physical schooling academics mentioned this usually was anticipated of them. More than to carry out their duties as sports activities academics, they’d be requested to make sure that self-discipline was maintained on campus – that college students adopted guidelines, didn’t get into fights, didn’t skip lessons, didn’t loiter on campus, or misbehave with academics or different college students.

“In some schools these teachers are asked to run small errands or do some small jobs around the school,” Kumar mentioned. “Because they are perceived as less important than other subject teachers.”

The principal of one other faculty in Thiruvarur defined that it didn’t have a sanctioned publish for a bodily schooling instructor as a result of it had solely 90 college students. Deviselvam identified that in response to a 1997 authorities order by the Tamil Nadu authorities, colleges may have one bodily schooling instructor for each 250 college students. But Deviselvam added that now, the federal government mandated that there may solely be one bodily instructor for each 400 college students. “So, if a school has 399 students, it would not be eligible for a physical education teacher,” Suresh mentioned. “In what world is that fair?”

The principal defined that the Thiruvarur faculty had an settlement with a instructor from one other faculty, whereby the instructor visited the varsity for a number of hours each week. He additionally famous that the varsity had acquired some sports activities supplies from the federal government.

But like in lots of different colleges, I observed that the playground was overgrown with weeds. According to 2022 knowledge from the Unified District Information System for Education, solely 77% of faculties in Tamil Nadu have playgrounds. In its capital metropolis, 367 schools out of 1,434 colleges do not need playgrounds. In 2022, the Madras High Court handed an order directing the state to take steps to make sure that each authorities and personal colleges had a playground on their campuses.

TN Raghu, a sports activities journalist from Tamil Nadu identified that the scenario was not significantly better in non-public colleges. He mentioned many colleges are arrange in congested areas the place there may be inadequate house for lecture rooms, not to mention a playground. “I don’t know on what basis these schools are issued permits,” he mentioned. “How can we allow a school to be constructed in an area where you can’t ensure a playground?”

Five months in the past, representatives of the bodily schooling academics’ affiliation waited in line for hours to satisfy Tamil Nadu’s schooling minister with an inventory of ten calls for, together with that colleges be supplied with correct playgrounds. “They always keep the physical education teachers as their last priority,” Suresh mentioned, half laughing. “But we appreciated the fact that even though we went in last, he still patiently listened to us.” Suresh mentioned the minister advised the affiliation members that a few of their calls for can be thought of.

The affiliation additionally demanded that the federal government publish and distribute a bodily schooling textbook that academics may use for instructing. Suresh mentioned academics had been arguing for years that their topic additionally deserved a e-book that dealt systematically with its theoretical features.

“The minister agreed to this demand but so far, we haven’t seen a physical copy,” he mentioned. “There is a soft copy available online. There is no word yet on when the book will get published and distributed among students.”

With all these shortfalls, bodily schooling academics will be essential to serving to college students achieve some coaching in sports activities and athletics. Vithya and Nitya Ramraj, 25-year-old twins from Coimbatore, whose father is a minivan driver, studied in a government-aided faculty up until Class 6. They recounted that their bodily schooling instructor suggested their mom to confess her daughters to the Government Sports Hostel for ladies in Erode as a result of she felt that they’d nice potential to turn into athletes, however that the varsity lacked the amenities to coach them.

When I spoke to them in September, Nithya was coaching for the 100-metre hurdles, and Vithya was coaching for the 400-metre hurdles. “Neither we nor our family have any idea about sports,” Vithya mentioned. “We would simply play around on the ground, but this teacher saw something in us that we did not see ourselves. My teacher told our mother that she was certain that we had the abilities to compete professionally.”

When Vithya received her first national-level observe occasion, she met the instructor to thank her. “We didn’t really have a playground in the school and so the teacher knew that we would not be able to develop our skills if we remained in the same school,” Vithya mentioned.

A couple of weeks after I met them, Vithya equalled PT Usha’s 39-year-old report within the 400-metre hurdles on the heats of the Asian Games.

Rajan defined that sports activities and bodily schooling weren’t solely necessary as a result of college students may win medals, however that additionally they contributed to all-round growth. “The belief often is that children who play sports don’t study well,” Rajan mentioned. “This is actually not true, children who play sports study better.” He added, “For other teachers, the aim is to get the child to pass an exam. Sports has a more long-term impact.”

Indeed, a 2016 paper on the connection between bodily exercise, health, cognitive perform, and tutorial achievement in youngsters famous that “a bulk of the research findings support the view that physical fitness, single bouts of physical activity, and participation in physical activity interventions benefit children’s mental functioning.” It famous particularly that well-designed research with controls for variables that might distort outcomes “consistently reveal that physically fit children perform better on cognitive tests than less-fit children”.

Further, younger sports activities individuals can entry employment quotas for presidency jobs on the Central and state degree in the event that they graduate from Class 12 and have represented their state or the nation at one in every of a number of recognised sporting occasions or competitions. “We are the ones who can help them find jobs in the future too,” Rajan mentioned.

In Savalakaran, Muthu Kumar offers steering to his college students by advising them on faculties they’ll apply to and avail of sports activities quotas – he additionally encourages them to write down authorities exams in order that they’ll procure jobs by means of quotas. “It was sir who advised me about where I can study,” mentioned Priyadarshini who’s now pursuing a grasp’s in arithmetic at a authorities faculty within the district.

Before he despatched them off to their properties after apply, Kumar checked with each pupil if they’d had eaten a snack. He often suggested them to carry an egg from residence – college students who couldn’t afford eggs on sure days generally introduced boiled pulses. The expense on this meals will be tough for fogeys, Kumar mentioned, however added that they’d “begun to understand the positives of sports and take a special interest in their children’s sports careers”.

This is clear in different methods, too. Kumar mentioned that when he first began coaching college students, dad and mom of feminine college students have been against the thought of their daughters even sporting shorts. On the sphere that day, all the ladies wore shorts – they turned into trousers, or salwar bottoms earlier than they walked residence. “Even the students would feel awkward initially,” Kumar mentioned. “It took them time to get used to it. Now all they care about is the game.”

Kumar bemoaned the truth that his restricted sources prevented him from providing the scholars all of the alternatives he needed to supply them, akin to coaching in particular person sports activities.

“I have two options – put all my energy, time and focus on one student or train a large number of students so they can all have a chance at either competing professionally or be eligible for the sports quota,” he mentioned. “If I had at least one other teacher with me, it would be possible to also focus on individual sports.”

Hema, one in every of Kumar’s former college students, mentioned she had additionally nurtured a ardour for working – however as a result of Kumar was unable to provide her sufficient particular person coaching, she too joined the soccer workforce.

Despite these obstacles, college students stay grateful for these academics’ contributions to their growth. “My parents are farmers and nobody had any idea about the game. Today my brother also plays,” mentioned Priyadarshini, who was the primary from the varsity to characterize the state on the nationwide degree.

Kumar continues to see success along with his college students. Just this 12 months, he mentioned, seven of his college students had been chosen in numerous soccer groups of various age teams on the state and nationwide ranges. He hoped by the top of the 12 months that quantity would rise to 10. “Hopefully, in the near future, I will represent India,” Priyadarshini mentioned. “But so many students may never realise their potential if they don’t have a physical education teacher at their school.”

This reporting is made attainable with help from Report for the World, an initiative of The GroundTruth Project.