For years, I’ve assumed that most individuals don’t want third-party antivirus instruments and have cheerily handed this suggestion alongside to others.

After all, Microsoft’s Windows Security suite (also referred to as Windows Defender or Microsoft Defender) offers built-in virus safety in your PC, and it doesn’t value a dime. I’ve been utilizing it for years, and the final time I can recall having virus issues on my PC was effectively over a decade in the past.

And but, trying round for affirmation of this long-held perception rapidly turns up an alternate universe, stuffed with consultants who insist that everybody must be paying for antivirus software program. This recommendation comes not simply from the businesses that promote antivirus suites, however from respected websites that carry out antivirus software program critiques (PCWorld included).

On high of that, practically every laptop I’ve reviewed for PCWorld has include some type of antivirus trialware from firms like McAfee and Norton. Those firms pay PC makers for placement, which wouldn’t make sense if nobody purchased the merchandise, proper?

At this level, I’ve heard sufficient questions from readers—and members of the family—that I made a decision to dig slightly deeper. What I’ve discovered is that my preliminary assumptions have been largely right: Most individuals can certainly skate by with out additional antivirus software program. But that doesn’t imply everybody ought to, or that you simply shouldn’t take any additional precautions to remain protected.

As an preliminary sanity test on my antivirus assumptions, I did the obvious factor potential and put out the question on Twitter: Does Microsoft’s built-in Windows Security software present sufficient safety for typical PC customers?

The consensus reply was sure, with caveats.

Jared Newman / Foundry

Justin Duino of How-To Geek pointed to his website’s helpful article on the subject, which really helpful Windows Security along with Malwarebytes’ free malware scanner. My fellow freelance journalist Rob Pegoraro additionally called out a Wirecutter article that came to the same conclusion. Another author chimed in with a similar recommendation.

The reasoning is straightforward: Windows Security rivals different applications at sniffing out viruses. While this wasn’t at all times the case, Microsoft’s detection has improved significantly lately, to the purpose that the unbiased AV-TEST Institute recurrently awards it a 5.5 or perhaps a excellent 6 out 6 in safety, usability, and efficiency, beating industry averages.

Perhaps extra importantly, safety is decentralized now, so a single virus scanner is not your solely line of safety. Some examples:

• Major net browsers can detect and block malicious web sites on their very own, due to instruments like Google Safe Browsing.
• Those browsers may warn you in the event you’re about to obtain an unrecognized program.
• Major e mail suppliers, similar to Gmail and Yahoo, scan attachments for viruses earlier than you’ll be able to even obtain them.
• Those similar e mail suppliers’ spam filters do an ideal job at preserving malicious emails out of your inbox and warning you of potential phishing schemes.
• The SmartScreen filter constructed into Windows will warn you in the event you’re trying to put in unrecognized software program.

Antivirus, ultimately, is simply one other line of protection. For many individuals, Microsoft’s built-in defenses must be robust sufficient.

Getting a second opinion

Jared Newman / Foundry

So why to do some people advocate Malwarebytes as a further layer of safety? Mainly as a result of it’s good to have one other set of eyes in your pc.

Last 12 months, as an illustration, I ran a scan in Malwarebytes, and picked up a set of doubtless undesirable applications tied to my set up of Chrome. While my Chrome set up gave the impression to be working high quality—with no sketchy toolbars or search redirects that I may see—this did persuade me to delete my sync data from Chrome, reset its settings, and carry out a contemporary Chrome set up. (I think it was a browser extension behaving badly.)

But Malwarebytes has its downsides as effectively. If you’re not cautious throughout set up, it’ll mechanically set up its personal extension in all of your browsers, and the free model routinely nags you with improve prompts. Also, until you disable its real-time protections (that are solely obtainable as a 14-day trial totally free customers), they’ll override Microsoft’s personal virus scanner.

I should often set up Malwarebytes to get a second opinion on my pc’s well being, however for now, I’m leaving it off my PC as effectively.

Ian Paul / Foundry

To be clear, third-party antivirus software program isn’t a grift with no precise utility behind it. While many individuals don’t have to pay for antivirus software program, there are nonetheless some causes to think about doing so:

• You want extra assist with safety: Some antivirus applications provide additional safety features past the realm of conventional virus scanning. Avast, as an illustration, can monitor webcam use and allow you to block untrusted apps from capturing video, and it will possibly additionally warn you if any of your on-line passwords are concerned in a safety breach. (Many premium AV suites now provide identification safety options.)
• You’re seeking to bundle: In addition to additional safety features, some antivirus applications provide instruments that you simply would possibly in any other case buy individually. Norton 360 Deluxe, as an illustration, contains its personal password supervisor and cloud storage service. Avast One has a built-in VPN and a brief file cleaner.
• You need extra sorts of safety: Some third-party instruments provide further strategies of safety that aren’t constructed into Windows. AVG’s “Behavior Shield,” as an illustration, can search for patterns of malicious habits even when it hasn’t detected a virus, whereas Avast One has ransomware safety that stops apps from encrypting your recordsdata with out permission. (Windows gives this as effectively, however not by default.) Secure file deletion, shopping safety, and different useful options can be found in lots of premium safety packages as effectively. Antivirus suites additionally sometimes present safety for cellular units in addition to private computer systems.

All of those additional options, nevertheless, could bloat up your pc, affecting efficiency and getting in your manner, and they may not even be the very best instruments for the job. I’d a lot relatively use a dedicated password manager than one which’s bundled with antivirus software program, and if I wanted a VPN, I’d wish to choose the provider myself. That stated, there’s robust attraction in an all-in-one answer for individuals who don’t wish to deal with a mish-mash of applications, and trendy antivirus suites provide precisely that.

While additional antivirus software program was important within the early days of non-public computing, lately it’s only one potential instrument within the broader safety arsenal, which also needs to embody robust passwords, two-factor authentication, sturdy data backups, and a wholesome dose of widespread sense. On that, at the least, the consultants appear to be in complete concord.

Want extra tech recommendation like this? Sign up for my Advisorator newsletter, the place a model of this column initially appeared.