Good morning.

Last week India became the fourth ever country to land a spacecraft on the moon, and the primary to the touch down efficiently close to its south pole. It was hailed as successful for “budget” missions, with the undertaking costing £60m, lower than half of the £131m it price Christopher Nolan to make his 2014 house epic, Interstellar.

The triumph was greeted with wild pleasure in India, with the prime minister, Narendra Modi, saying it “mirrors the aspirations and capabilities of 1.4 billion Indians”.

Others level out that 280 million of these Indian residents still don’t have toilets, and maybe Modi ought to repair that earlier than funding additional house exploration. In the UK, the same old voices are utilizing the lunar touchdown to additional their argument that we should always cease sending help to India.

But are such criticisms honest? For at present’s e-newsletter I talked to Martin Barstow, professor of astrophysics and house science, and director of strategic partnerships at Space Park Leicester, which was opened by British astronaut Tim Peake final yr.

In depth: ‘The money you spend in space pays people’s wages, creates jobs and helps financial development’

***

A brief historical past of India’s house programme

India’s house programme was established in 1962, a yr after John F Kennedy set a goal to land an American on the moon by the top of the last decade. But it wasn’t till the Nineteen Seventies and 80s that the Indian Space Research Organisation (ISRO) actually acquired going, utilizing satellites to map and survey crops, monitor harm from pure disasters and erosion, and to convey telemedicine and telecommunication to distant rural areas.

The nation now has one of many world’s largest house programmes. It designs, builds, launches, operates and tracks the total spectrum of satellites, rockets and lunar and interplanetary probes. It brings priceless status to India: witness Modi’s beaming face on the assembly of the Brics emerging nations this week, when he declared the lunar touchdown “the movement for new, developing India”. He resisted the temptation to attract comparisons with the Russian delegation’s effort – their Luna-25 spacecraft crashed into the moon 4 days earlier.

***

How India paid for it

In quick, it operates to a good price range and manages to outperform expectations. The ISRO has a reputation for parsimony, with Indian house scientists paid one-fifth of the worldwide common, in accordance with a former ISRO chair. And though India’s authorities allotted the equal of £1.3bn for the division of house for the fiscal yr ending in March, it spent about 25% much less. By distinction, Nasa has a £20bn price range for the present yr.

In any case, Martin Barstow has no truck with the argument that it’s ridiculous for India to spend something on house exploration when 10% of its inhabitants still live below the $2.15 a day poverty line.

“I see this argument all the time and it is really missing the point. The space science bit is a very small fraction of the programme,” says Barstow. Most of it’s spent “keeping people alive” on Earth, he provides. “That’s helping people with agriculture, helping people in poor areas who don’t have good communication or infrastructure. It’s really about developing the country.”

He hears the identical arguments within the UK. “People ask: ‘Why do we do space in the UK? We can spend that money building hospitals.’ But all the money you spend in space isn’t really spent in space. It is spent on the ground. It pays people’s wages, it develops high-tech jobs. It supports economic growth. In the UK, space brings £17bn a year to the economy.”

***

Is it time for the UK to cease sending help to India?

The Foreign Office, which distributes help, sent India £33.4m in money in 2022/23. Former Brexit social gathering MEP Ben Habib mentioned the lunar touchdown confirmed it was time for the UK to cease sending India any cash in any respect: “It is odd, to put it mildly, that the UK gives increasing amounts of aid to India, a country with a space programme and an economy bigger than our own,” he grumbled.

Barstow sees it in a different way: “We still need to support India, which remains a poor country,” he says. GDP per capita in India is £1,789, in contrast with £36,863 within the UK. Almost 20% of Indian households – about 280 million individuals – don’t use any rest room facility, according to India’s national family health survey. Then there are arguments about the soft power that such aid allows the UK to wield and reparations owed to India as a result of legacies of empire, neither of which claims are dented by India’s supposed extravagance in investing in house exploration.

***

What subsequent for India’s house ambitions?

Next, India desires to ship three astronauts into house with a mission referred to as Gaganyaan. Although an Indian flew to orbit on a Soviet spacecraft in 1984, the nation has by no means managed this feat by itself. The undertaking was scheduled to be full by 2023 however has faced numerous delays.

It additionally hopes to launch another mission to Mars, after its Mangalyaan orbiter efficiently noticed the planet from 2014 to 2022. A photo voltaic observatory referred to as Aditya-L1 can be within the pipeline, in addition to an Earth remark satellite tv for pc constructed collectively with Nasa.

What else we’ve been studying

• Thomas Hobbs speaks to a few of the largest names in hip-hop to get their reflections on the defining moments of the style over the past 5 a long time. Nimo

• “They see him as a spiritual leader, as a messiah.” Zoe Williams meets Andrew Tate’s nemesis, Matt Shea, whose second documentary in regards to the misogynistic kickboxer airs this week. Helen

• For the New Yorker (£), Dhruv Khullar goes to excessive lengths to chronicle the affect of maximum warmth on the human physique, together with placing himself in a 40C chamber whereas strolling on a treadmill. An interesting, terrifying learn. Nimo

• To hell with good intentions? Joel Snape asks whether or not you must fear about figuring out too arduous. Helen

• Two years after his 13-year-old daughter’s preventable dying, Paul Laity displays on his life with out her. The article is in equal measure heartbreaking and revelatory because it describes the “litany of failures” within the hospital within the days earlier than Martha’s dying. Nimo

The entrance pages

The Guardian print version begins the week with “Ultra-processed foods causing a ‘tidal wave of harm’, say experts”. “Great British food scandal” – that’s the Daily Mirror on this “processed hell” of our food plan. “NHS ‘trying to erase women’” says the Daily Mail about one thing referred to as the Rainbow Badge scheme, which it says is about eradicating gendered language from hospitals. The i has “Tory ‘big beasts’ facing wipeout at next election – as Dorries opens up new splits” whereas on the identical theme the Daily Express says “Tory infighting will gift Labour the keys to No10”. “Electronic tagging plan to stop migrants fleeing” is the highest story within the Times whereas the Daily Telegraph goes with “Braverman: police must investigate every theft”. Lead story in at present’s Financial Times is “China’s sluggish economy will weigh on global trade, western groups warn”.

Today in Focus

Revisited: Trafficked: Marta – half 4

The story of a Ukrainian woman who escaped modern slavery within the UK. Annie Kelly stories

Cartoon of the day | Edith Pritchett

Sign up for Inside Saturday to see extra of Edith Pritchett’s cartoons, the very best Saturday journal content material and an unique look behind the scenes.

The Upside

A bit of fine information to remind you that the world’s not all unhealthy

Jimmy Lippert Thyden grew up in Virginia understanding he was adopted and that his organic household was from Chile. But he didn’t know that he had been taken away from his delivery mom and, like 20,000 different infants throughout Augusto Pinochet’s regime, offered for revenue.

With the assistance of an at-home DNA equipment, he discovered his delivery mom and in August met her for the first time in Chile with the phrases, “Hola, Mamá … Te amo mucho.” “Hello, Mom. I love you so much.”

Sign up here for a weekly roundup of The Upside, despatched to you each Sunday

Bored at work?

And lastly, the Guardian’s puzzles are right here to maintain you entertained all through the day – with lots extra on the Guardian’s Puzzles app for iOS and Android. Until tomorrow.