Editor’s be aware: This is the primary of a two-part sequence on sports activities betting in Kansas. Part two will publish subsequent week.

Kansas taxpayers subsidize the hundreds of thousands of {dollars} nationwide sports activities playing apps hand out to bettors for his or her preliminary wagers that get them within the behavior of playing.

The new sports activities betting trade additionally makes hardly any income for the state, amounting to a small drop within the bucket of the state’s multi-billion greenback working price range.

What’s extra, applications devoted to supporting bettors with playing habit solely get peanuts from that income. Instead, the overwhelming majority of the {dollars} are positioned in a fund geared toward attracting a sports activities crew to the state — an idea that the fund would by no means realistically be capable of afford.

A majority of state lawmakers — each Republicans and Democrats — legalized sports activities betting with caveats that closely favor casinos and on-line sports activities betting apps however lack high quality security nets from the hurt it has on some Kansans.

Legislators may change that by amending the legislation. But they confirmed little urge for food for it in Topeka this spring after the legislation went into impact virtually a 12 months in the past. And that’s after the New York Times called out the Legislature for bowing to sports activities betting lobbyists who swarmed Topeka to get a legalization legislation enacted.

Republican Rep. Paul Waggoner repeatedly known as the proposal a nasty deal for Kansas residents. One of the principle sticking factors is a provision that permits casinos to supply tax-free promotions to bettors — a software that can be utilized to get folks hooked on betting whereas creating no income for the state.

“It would be like a liquor store,” Waggoner mentioned, “having promotional drinks to get people really into vodka and never having to pay taxes on that liquor. But of course it’s designed to drum up business.”

Meanwhile, the state has made less than $6 million in the first fiscal year of this system although folks wager $1.6 billion on the outcomes of video games, an athlete’s efficiency and even far-out wagers just like the timed length of the national anthem earlier than the Super Bowl.

But supporters of the legislation contend Kansas is in step with the 37 other states that have joined the rush to legalize sports betting.

Take former House Speaker Ron Ryckman, for instance. Lobbyists for sports activities betting apps just lately pointed to the one-time Republican chief as a champion of the legislation. He contends the legislation displays one of the best practices established in different states that legalized sports activities playing, and the legislation now provides Kansans a authorized solution to do one thing they had been already doing illegally.

Ryckman additionally mentioned it was essential for Kansas to get the soar on Missouri, which nonetheless hasn’t legalized sports activities betting.

“Now we are getting thousands of Missouri residents,” Ryckman mentioned, “coming into Kansas to place their bets every week, and Kansas keeps that tax revenue.”

Yet the entire income from sports activities betting to the state represents simply 0.05% p.c of all tax income. It’s a miniscule sum of money for the state, and never even sufficient to restore a bridge on Interstate 70 in Wyandotte County.

Additionally, lawmakers have but to indicate curiosity in an overhaul of the legislation. The overwhelming majority of Democratic lawmakers backed the proposal that was pushed by Republicans. And Democratic Gov. Laura Kelly signed the invoice into legislation with out elevating any objections to the way it was crafted. She even celebrated sports activities playing opening by making the primary authorized wager within the state and carrying a jacket selling Barstool Sportsbook, one of many a number of on-line betting apps that flooded the state with legalized betting.

Dylan Lysen

/

Kansas News Service

After reporting about how Kansas obtained lower than $1,200 out of greater than $194 million wager the month the Kansas City Chiefs gained the Super Bowl, Kelly mentioned she had some considerations in regards to the legislation. She has but to specify what adjustments she would possibly need to see.

Her spokesperson didn’t go far to make clear that.

“She agrees there are aspects of the sports betting legislation that could be improved,” Zach Fletcher mentioned in an e-mail. “She will continue to discuss any potential changes with legislators.”

Waggoner mentioned authorized sports activities betting is a nasty deal for Kansas taxpayers as a result of lobbyists primarily wrote the invoice. Those similar lobbyists descended on Topeka in droves to push for the brand new trade within the state by providing lawmakers cash, single-malt whiskey and cigars, The New York Times reported.

The invoice then sailed by means of the Legislature late within the 2022 session, throughout a interval when payments are made in convention committees — the place a handful of lawmakers craft a plan by negotiating between the House and Senate and most don’t get an opportunity to supply enhancements.

“The details of this,” Waggoner mentioned, “were not really well known or really analyzed in any serious sense when the Legislature passed this.”

Under the legislation, casinos don’t pay taxes on promotional bets, which the sports activities betting apps supply liberally. Anytime a bettor logs into DraftKings or FanDuel, they are going to see a number of totally different promotional wager alternatives. A typical promotion is handing over $100 of free bets when a bettor deposits $100 of their very own cash — immediately doubling the cash they’ll play with. Some even supply referral bonuses that give gamblers extra free bets in the event that they discover a solution to get their buddies and acquaintances hooked too.

That’s a approach the casinos get bettors to start out enjoying. The casinos then don’t pay any state taxes on the income from the free wager till they get their promotional a reimbursement. However, the casinos nonetheless have to pay federal taxes on them. So in observe, the state is subsidizing promoting to get folks excited by sports activities betting.

In flip, Kansas makes little or no cash off of sports activities playing. It solely taxes 10% of the revenue the casinos make. That’s akin to the charges of different Midwest states with authorized sports activities playing, nevertheless it pales compared to Rhode Island and New York, which impose a 51% tax.

In June, the top of the fiscal 12 months, Kansas reported earning $5.8 million. That’s lower than 0.1% of the state’s $9 billion normal fund price range. And solely a tiny fraction of that income — roughly $100,000 — is put towards funds that assist individuals who endure from sports activities playing habit.

But the state nonetheless earned greater than it anticipated. Cory Thone, a spokesperson for the Kansas Lottery, mentioned the state initially estimated making simply $1.8 million within the first fiscal 12 months. The state pushed the estimation as much as $5.6 million within the spring and exceeded that as effectively.

No month higher encapsulates the profit to casinos than February 2023 — the identical month the hometown Kansas City Chiefs had been enjoying within the Super Bowl. That made the most important sports activities betting day within the nation even larger in Kansas. Yet the state made virtually nothing off of it.

According to the Wichita Beacon, the casinos in Kansas took on about $194 million in bets. Once the mud settled, the state earned simply $1,134. Meanwhile, the casinos paid out $468,000 in federal taxes, which is often smaller than what the state is owed.

Richard Auxier, senior coverage affiliate for Tax Policy Center, mentioned promotional bets suppress the sum of money the state collects. And he mentioned permitting the casinos to supply the untaxed promotional bets is downright nonsensical as a result of sportsbooks don’t want tax incentives to start working in Kansas.

Subsidizing a brand new trade in that approach is supposed to spur on a enterprise that the state thinks could wrestle or deliver a brand new trade to the state that in any other case wouldn’t. Sports betting — which is backed by nationwide sports activities betting apps that advertise basically everywhere — doesn’t fall in that class.

Auxier mentioned the sports activities betting apps had been going to start out working in Kansas as rapidly as they may as soon as the trade was authorized.

“It’s a complete misunderstanding of both what the product is and what the market is,” Auxier mentioned. “Why legislators decided we should give away tax breaks on free promotional bets is beyond me.”

One doable cause is that state lawmakers gave it to lobbyists as a result of they requested for it. Waggoner argues they selected what the lobbyist wished over what advantages Kansas.

“All we ended up with,” Waggoner mentioned, “was just a very sweet deal for the casinos and nobody else.”

Dylan Lysen

/

Kansas News Service

Ryckman downplayed the promotional wager tax credit score, evaluating it to a barbecue joint giving out free samples. However, he didn’t reply to questions on whether or not the tax credit score was included as a result of lobbyists wished it.

“Sports betting operators who give customers free money to place bets,” Ryckman mentioned, “should not have to pay tax on that money.”

Ryckman additionally argues the low income in February had nothing to do with promotional bets and the good thing about the promotions have already dropped off for the casinos. Instead, he believes the state noticed little income in February as a result of many Kansans had been amassing on their winnings when the Chiefs had been topped Super Bowl champions.

Waggoner mentioned adjustments nonetheless have to occur. But when he regarded into amending the legislation this previous spring to extend the tax charge from 10% to twenty%, he realized the Kansas Lottery entered five-year contracts with state casinos to manage sports activities betting.

He was warned that if the state adjustments the tax charge, the casinos may sue for a breach of contract, he mentioned.

But the legislators might be able to change whether or not promotional bets are tax exempt. And they may all the time transfer round the place the income is used. Waggoner suggests extra of the funding ought to go towards aiding folks with playing habit or conducting a examine on sports activities playing within the state to see how it’s affecting folks.

But Ryckman contends adjustments usually are not wanted. At least for now. He mentioned the legislation is in its infancy and it seems to be working easily.

“Lawmakers will continue to keep a close eye on this issue,” Ryckman mentioned, “but I think it’s premature to discuss any changes at this point.”

Dylan Lysen studies on politics for the Kansas News Service. You can observe him on Twitter @DylanLysen or e-mail him at dlysen (at) kcur (dot) org.

The Kansas News Service is a collaboration of KCUR, Kansas Public Radio, KMUW and High Plains Public Radio centered on well being, the social determinants of well being and their connection to public coverage. 

Kansas News Service tales and images could also be republished by information media for free of charge with correct attribution and a hyperlink to ksnewsservice.org.